We tried many toilet seats from different brands for finding out the ones that are more comfortable & don’t move while you place your big cheeks on the seat 😉
Below are the top 10 picks that we think are the best choice for your next purchase as per our experience.
Table of Contents
Best Toilet Seats (Top 10 Picks)
1. Bemis 1500EC
The first on our list is the Bemis 1500EC toilet seat. This unit comes into shapes; elongated and round. It is one of the most popular and high-quality toilet seats. It is effortless to install this toilet seat, and you can do it on your own.
You do not need to get down on your hands and knees to fix it on the pot. The locking wing nuts are easy to use; all you need is to fix and wing the nuts. There are total bumpers on the bottom of the seat, and they hold it during use.
The best part for me about the Bemis 1500EC seat is the bumpers, which prevent the shifting of the seat. The wooden material is super easy to clean and features a water and moisture-resistant coating. However, the only thing that we did not appreciate about this toilet seat is the peeling of the paint.
- It is pretty easy to install and replace.
- The hinges are of plastic; easy to lock and unlock.
- It goes well with all elongated toilets.
- Water and moisture-resistant seat.
- The hinges can be replaced easily
- The toilet seat resists moisture
- The shape is elongated
- The paint comes off after a while
There is not a lot of creativity when it comes to toilet seats but the features can determine whether it is a good purchase or not. The water resistance and hard material of the Bemis 1500EC make it a long-term partner for your bathroom’s fresh new look!
2. MAYFAIR 841EC 047
Next on our list is Mayfair 841EC 047 wooden toilet seat. Wood adds a different aesthetic touch to your bathroom; that a plastic option cannot match. The most appealing part about this unit is; you can choose between a variety of colors and it added something to the luxury feel of my washroom as well.
The overall finish and look of this toilet seat are stunning. Also, this seat is supported by a fastening system that prevents movement and twisting of the hinges. Not to mention, the seat’s wings are properly covered with hard plastic that resists slipping in the holes.
The cleaning of this toilet seat is easy; you can remove it with a quick-release system. However, the only thing that we do not appreciate about this product is the sensitive material; you cannot wash the seat with any other liquid; only mild soap and water are allowed.
- This unit fits all types of toilets
- Easy installation and removal
- This product carries weight properly
- No peeling or cracking of the paint
The Mayfair 841EC looks clean and new for years. It is comfortable and will not easily crack or de-shape. One of the best choices out there, this seat is not just comfortable, it looks good too!
- The hinges can be replaced easily
- The toilet seat resists moisture
- The shape is elongated
- The paint comes off after a while
3. Centoco 1600-001
First things first. An elongated toilet must be aligned with an elongated toilet seat. Centoco 1600-001 is an elongated toilet seat that goes well with such types of toilets. Moreover, this seat has a fantastic fitting; no more sliding and twisting of the seat. This unit is a plastic toilet seat that resists cracking and staining.
Moreover, the hinges are powerful enough to reduce the strain on the toilet seat. This product will carry the weight properly when a person sits down. You can choose between four colors.
Moreover, the bumpers protect the toilet when the seat is slammed to closure. It is quite easy to install and assemble this toilet seat and we were able to assemble it quickly. Just screw the nuts, and you are good to go.
- This unit features no-peeling or cracking.
- The assembling process is easy.
- The bumpers protect the overall seat.
- Strong hinges support the weight.
- The paint does not come off easily
- The hinges are really strong
- The assembling is quite easy
- Fitting is an issue
Toilet seats are all about comfort and cleanliness. The Centoco is comfortable for sure, and we thought that it was because of the good material, and a good fit with the toilet that made it stay in place. The basic problem with seats is that if they are not a proper fit, they tend to move and that causes discomfort. However, the Centoco stays in place, and what adds to its charm? This seat also has colors! What more can one want?
4. KOHLER K-4639-47
Next on our list is Kohler K-4639-47 is one amazing product. This unit is available in both round and elongated shapes. The Kohler comes with a lid and a standard seat. You can choose from a variety of colors.
This model is made out of plastic and features no-cracking or peeling. Both round and elongated versions come with an enamel finish and come with quiet-close and quick-release hinges but I liked the round one better. The quiet close system makes sure that the lid is not slammed or bent. The quick-release system ensures that it is easy to clean the toilet.
Not to mention, this seat comes with a grip-tight bumper; so that there are no shifts between the work. However, this unit does not go well with a bidet.
- Slow closure and removal.
- Easy cleaning process.
- A quick-release system makes installation and replacement easy.
- The tight bumper prevents shifting.
Kohler is a famous brand and now you must know why! As we mentioned earlier, there are not many features that one looks for in a toilet seat. However, some of the selected items that we tried were judged upon installation, shifting, and fit.
Kohler fits all these criteria well and that is why we can recommend it to all those who are looking for a comfortable seat but do not want it to look plain and old!
- The closure is smooth
- Installation and replacement are easy
- The hinges are of good quality
- The color fades after a sometimes
5. Mayfair 115EC
Next on our list is another premium option by Mayfair 115EC; this unit is made out of wood and is considered a high-end product. Not to mention, even though this seat is a wooden unit, it comes with a soft-close system that prevents the banging of the seat when slammed down.
The adjustable hinges are of high quality, which makes it easier to install this unit and our team loved the quick installation process. The adjustable hinges also make the installation and assembling process easy. Mayfair 115EC is sturdy and looks aesthetic as well. This seat resists scratching, and it is ideal for a luxe bidet.
The fastening system ensures stability and carries the weight well. However, the only thing that we did not like about this unit is the discoloration issue.
- The hinges are of high quality.
- This unit fits all kinds of toilets.
- The fastening system is reliable.
- The adjustable hinges offer easy installation.
- The hinges are adjustable
- The color does not fade
- The seating is comfortable
- It does not prevent moisture
The names might be similar but each toilet seat on this list is the result of some exploration by our team. Mayfair is a good choice as it fits all kinds of toilets and the material is strong enough to go a long way.
6. Vive Toilet Seat Riser
The Vive toilet seat riser is a bit different from the rest. This unit is ideal for disabled persons, as this toilet seat comes with handles and padded arms. The ergonomics and the whole infrastructure of this toilet are premium.
This product is safe as it comes with an elevated extender. The Vive toilet seat riser is portable, functional, and looks decent too.
Moreover, it is also ideal for people who are up to 300 pounds. The lid and the set of handles with paddings add more safety to the product. Not to mention, we are impressed by the convenient installation of this seat. No need to involve any tools for the installation of the padded seat.
The Vive Toilet Seat Riser is also compatible with both round and elongated toilets. But, we would recommend you measure your toilet before buying this seat.
- This unit is compatible with round and elongated shapes.
- The grip and handles are soft and comforting.
- The installation process is easy.
- The material is water-resistant.
Water-resistant material might sound unnecessary to some people but it is a cool feature and you must select a seat that does not absorb moisture!
The hardness of the seat depends on how water resistant it is, and the Vive Toilet Seat Riser comes with handles that make it easier for older people to lower down and get up. We liked this seat for all the features, and so will you.
- The seat resits the water
- The seat is adjustable and comfortable
- It can hold up to 3000 pounds
- The closure is rough
7. MAYFAIR 883SLOWA
Next on our list is an exciting toilet seat. Another attractive option from Mayfair 883SLOWA features a built-in extra lid for toilet training. This unit is a dual-performing seat that comes with an easy installation and clean-up process.
Moreover, the extra lid for toilet training is easy to clean and hygienic as well. This model by Mayfair is a genius approach and a modern way of using a bathroom. You do need to attach an extra kids’ potty lid for the training as per mom’s from our team suggestions.
The slow close features ensure safety while closing the lid. Also, if you do need the potty lid, you can easily remove it from the hinges. The high-gloss finish makes it waterproof and prevents scratching and peeling.
- It is a clutter-free modern toilet seat.
- This unit resists chipping and scratching.
- The seat is high in the fitting.
- Slow close features ensure no slamming.
The built-in lid and the training features make this seat a true family companion! Mayfair’s commitment to its customers is evident in the way they have thought about the juniors in the family too! The modern toilet seat is a good sight and will suit every member of your family.
- It is a waterproof seat
- Extra lid for potty seat attachment
- The closure does not slam
- The color fades with time
8. KOHLER K-4636-0
Another attractive option from Kohler. This unit is an extended version, but you can get the same round shape as well. This toilet seat fits any toilet; you need to worry about the fitting. Moreover, this product is made out of solid polypropylene, which prevents cracks, chips, staining, and scratches.
But, the only problem that we noticed in the unit is the trembling of the seat while sitting. But, the bumpers hold the seat tightly and securely. The hinges are well-protected and enhance the durability of the seat.
It is straightforward to incorporate the seat and install it. The cleaning process is also simple and I loved it; you can reach out to hard places to clean with ease. The slow-close technology will help you to close the lid without making any noise. We find this toilet seat much more attractive than Kohler 463947.
- This unit fits well with elongated toilets.
- The hinges match the color of the seat.
- The quick release makes no noise.
- Easy installation and cleaning process.
The hydraulic release makes the seat come down from a standing position and there is no loud noise, isn’t that a great feature? The Kohler brand is excellent when it comes to smooth finishing, and the easy installation adds to its rank. We liked this seat because it took two minutes to fix, and that is a big quality!
- The release makes no noise
- The material resists moisture
- The fitting of the unit is good
- The paint and color fade after some time
9. TOTO SS154#01
Next on our list is TOTO SS154#01; this toilet seat is made of high-impact polypropylene with a premium gloss finish. This unit resists chemical cleaning products; hence you can easily maintain the shine of the seat.
The soft-close technology prevents the lid from slamming, which leads to an enhanced lifespan. This toilet seat is an excellent option for a household having kids. The overall structure of the seat increases the comfort of the private area. However, you need to bend down on your knees to install this seat.
Moreover, you can choose from a variety of options and colors. But, we noticed one thing in this seat; this unit is a bit sloped. Hence. Some people may find this a bit uncomfortable.
- This unit prevents chemical stains.
- Water and moisture-resistant toilet seat.
- Highly comfortable with ergonomic design.
- High glass polypropylene material.
- The seat is made of high-quality material
- The closure is smooth
- The seat prevents chemical stain
- The hinges are of low quality
No chemical stains mean you can clean your bathroom and the toilet seat, and end up having a newer bathroom every time. You have to admit that the toilet seat can give away the age of your home more than the pictures hanging in the stairway! TOTO will keep the age of your home a secret, and the glossy surface will always look good!
10. BATH ROYALE BR620-00
The last on our list is Bath Royale BR620-00, and this unit comes in three colors. The toilet seats by this company are renowned. But, this model is a functional unit that features a soft-close mechanism that prevents slamming of the lid.
Not to mention, this seat is highly comfortable and will make you feel appropriately fitted. Not to mention, this toilet seat can hold up to 400 pounds. The four bumpers are powerful enough to carry this much weight.
The material is non-porous; hence, it prevents chipping, peeling, and fading. Moreover, this toilet seat has a high-gloss finish which makes it look premium.
- This unit is a sturdy piece made out of wood.
- The bumpers are strong enough to hold 400 lbs.
- The material is non-porous and prevents moisture build-up.
- Soft-close technology ensures slow closure.
Bath Royale is a royal addition to your bathroom as the wooden seat can go a long way and never look old or chafed! Moreover, the weight it can bear is more than other plastic options.
- The wooden seat quality is top notch
- The material is non-porous
- The paint does not fade or chips
- It does not come with an extra attachment
Factors to consider while buying a toilet seat:
Before buying any product, make sure that you are making an informed decision. By far, you must gain a deep understanding of the top ten best toilet seats. However, you need to explore the factors considered while buying a toilet seat.
This is one of the most important factors to consider. Easy installation is a critical element. You must be able to install or replace the toilet seat easily. Not to mention, easy installation leads to easy clean-up.
Before buying a toilet seat, make sure to know about your toilet bowl design. Not all toilet seats are compatible with all shapes. There are two basic shapes elongated and round. You first need to measure the length of your bowl before buying a toilet seat. A standard elongated bowl measures around 18-18.5 inches, and a round bowl is around 16.5 inches.
You cannot just buy a toilet seat in any color. You must choose a toilet seat that matches the color of the toilet bowl. However, you can also make a combination; but the wise decision is to choose the color that can pair with the bathroom design.
How we tested Toilet Seat
A comfortable Toilet Seat is a blessing. Having the right toilet seat can make all the difference in your overall bathroom experience. The right toilet seat should fit the size and shape of your toilet, feel comfortable when you sit on it and have features that meet your needs.
After shifting to my new place, I wanted comfortable toilet seats for all my bathrooms. When searching for a new Toilet Seat, look for one with a soft cushion or padded surface to provide extra comfort.
A good Toilet Seat should also be easy to clean and maintain, with a smooth surface that is resistant to scratches and stains. Some toilet seats are even designed with features such as anti-bacterial materials or odor neutralizers, which help keep the toilet smelling fresh.
I researched and decided to get durable plastic toilet seats with adjustable hinges for different seat sizes and a soft close feature. With so many options, it was important to narrow my search to the ones that met my criteria.
The shape is an important factor when testing a toilet seat. The shape must be such that it allows for proper and comfortable seating for the user. To do this, I used a ruler to measure different parts of the seat before buying it. This included measuring the length and width of the seat. Additionally, I checked for any sharp edges or bumps on the seat, which could cause discomfort while sitting.
Size is another important factor to consider when testing a toilet seat. The size should be such that it fits comfortably in the bathroom and doesn’t take up too much space. To measure this, I used a tape measure to measure the overall seat dimensions before buying it. Additionally, I checked if the seat was wide enough to provide adequate support for the user.
The material used in a toilet seat is important for its durability and comfort. To test this, I felt the surface of the seat before buying it. It should be smooth and comfortable to sit on without causing any discomfort or irritation. Additionally, the material should also be waterproof and easy to clean. I checked for these qualities by reading the material details on the packaging before buying it.
Installing a toilet seat is an important factor when testing one. To do this, I checked if any instructions in the package would help me with the installation. Additionally, I ensured that all the necessary tools for installation were included in the package before buying it.
Finally, overall comfort is an important factor to consider when testing a toilet seat. To test this, I sat on different seats to check if they provided adequate support and comfort. I also checked if the seat was easily adjusted according to one’s needs.
The lid should have a smooth closure and fit perfectly when closed. To test this, I opened and closed the lid several times to check if it was easy. Additionally, I also made sure that the lid didn’t wobble or move around while closing it.
Quality of paint:
The paint quality of the toilet seat also needs to be checked. To do this, I looked for any defects on the surface, such as chips or flaking paint, that could indicate poor-quality paint. Additionally, I checked if the color was even and consistent over the entire seat surface before buying it.
The hinges of the toilet seat should be sturdy and in working condition. To check this, I opened and closed the lid several times to ensure it was easy to do so without any effort. I also checked if any signs of rust on the hinges indicated poor quality material used.
What are the benefits of using a toilet seat?
Using a toilet seat prevents splashing and spillage in the restroom. It also adds comfort while sitting on the toilet, helps prevent user fatigue, and can improve your bathroom’s hygiene. Furthermore, a toilet seat can help protect against germs and bacteria by providing a barrier between the user and the toilet bowl.
Moreover, some toilet seats are designed to reduce noise levels when in use, making them more pleasant for everyone around you.
Finally, having a toilet seat is essential for children or elderly family members who may not have the necessary physical strength or dexterity to safely sit on an open bowl. A toilet seat helps ensure everyone has a safe and secure place to use.
What should I consider when buying a toilet seat?
When choosing a toilet seat, you will want to consider factors such as its size, shape, material type, style, and color. You’ll also want to ensure the toilet seat is compatible with your existing toilet, so measure both before purchasing.
Additionally, some seats come with additional features such as slow-close hinges or easy-clean surfaces. Lastly, you should consider your budget and determine which features are most important for you and your family’s needs.
How do I clean and maintain my toilet seat?
To keep your toilet seat looking and functioning at its best, it’s important to regularly clean and maintain it. Start by cleaning the surface with a soft cloth dampened in warm soapy water. After wiping down the seat, use a sanitizing solution such as diluted bleach or rubbing alcohol to further disinfect.
For harder-to-reach spots, you can use a toothbrush or an old rag to get into the crevices. Additionally, be sure to routinely check for any cracks or damage and replace the seat if necessary. Always remember to close the toilet lid before flushing! This will help prevent damage caused by splashing water.
Are there any special instructions for installing a toilet seat?
When installing a toilet seat, following the manufacturer’s instructions carefully is important. Depending on your seat type, you may need different tools, such as screwdrivers, wrenches, or drills.
Additionally, it’s important to remember that the seat should be firmly secured. If not properly installed, the seat could become loose or cause injury if someone were to sit on it. After installation, you should check again and ensure everything is securely fastened before using your new toilet seat!
Are there any safety precautions I should take when using a toilet seat?
Yes, taking safety precautions while using any type of bathroom fixture is important. For example, always ensure your toilet seat is securely fastened and inspect the seat for signs of wear or damage before each use.
Additionally, you should never step on the toilet lid as this can cause it to break or become loose. Close the toilet lid before flushing to prevent splashing and potential injury. By taking these safety measures, you can help ensure that everyone in your home has a safe and comfortable restroom experience.
Are there any special instructions for removing a toilet seat?
Yes, it’s important to take extra care when removing a toilet seat. Start by disconnecting the nuts and bolts that secure the seat to the bowl. Then, use a flathead screwdriver to remove any screws still in place.
After this, carefully lift the bowl seat and set it aside. Double-check to remove all screws and nuts before disposing of the old seat. Following these instructions ensures that your toilet seat is safely and properly removed for replacement or cleaning.
A toilet seat may be a basic selection for many, but these fixtures need to be sturdy, with a good finish so that your bathrooms and powder rooms look as graceful as ever! The toilet seats on this list are not just randomly picked. We tried each of these for installation, material, and comfort. You can select the one that suits you most.
I grew up on a small farm in New Jersey. We had a big family because my parents, my uncles and aunties all were living together on this farm so, you can imagine, it was always over crowded with people. But living in farm was really great because we had to do everything on our own and I learned so many things from my parents and uncles and aunties and that is where I found my passion for fixing things, whether it is renovating or designing, I was always there. Read more